Variety V[6, 3843] no finite basis
The variety generated by [6, 3843], Lee's semigroup L: all semigroups that satisfy every identity of L. It has no finite basis. It is self-dual, since L is anti-isomorphic to itself, and no other semigroup of order at most six generates it: the variety of a finitely based semigroup has a finite basis, and the identities below tell it apart from the varieties of B₂¹, A₂ᵍ and A₂¹.
No finite basis
For every n, the identity
x y₁²⋯yₙ² x ≈ x yₙ²⋯y₁² x
holds in L. In a word equal in L to the left side the squares stay blocks, in the forward or in the reverse order, and no derivation step with an identity in fewer variables passes from one order to the other. A finite set of identities uses boundedly many variables, so it misses one of these identities and is not a basis.
Argument: W. T. Zhang and Y. F. Luo (2011). The Lean theorem is on the page of [6, 3843]; see also the four semigroups without a finite basis.
The four varieties without a finite basis
V[6, 3843], V[6, 8564], V[6, 8878] and V[6, 13747] are distinct: each pair differs on one of these identities.
| Identity | L | B₂¹ | A₂ᵍ | A₂¹ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| x² ≈ x³ | holds | holds | fails | holds |
| xyx ≈ x²yx | holds | fails | fails | fails |
| x²y² ≈ xy²x | fails | holds | fails | fails |
Among the 681 finitely based varieties
L lies in none of them, so neither does this variety. Which of them lie in it is not decided here: without a finite basis there is no basis to evaluate.
The name is permanent: [6, 3843] is the only generator of order at most six. See how the varieties are named.